Cold Winters Theory: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
(added criticisms) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The Cold Winters Theory (CWT) posits that average IQs vary geographically due to the difficulty of surviving harsh colder climates selecting for higher IQ. The hypothesis | The Cold Winters Theory (CWT) posits that average IQs vary geographically due to the difficulty of surviving harsh colder climates selecting for higher IQ. The hypothesis may explain how racial IQ differences could emerge and remain stable. | ||
=== Origins === | === Origins === | ||
In the 1990s, Richard Lynn and J. Philippe Rushton | In the 1990s, Richard Lynn and J. Philippe Rushton published hypotheses regarding the evolutionary origin of human intelligence in cold environments.<ref name=":0">Donald I. Templer, John S. Stephens (2014) The relationship between IQ and climatic variables in African and Eurasian countries, Intelligence, Volume 46. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289614000877?via%3Dihub</ref> | ||
=== Evidence === | === Evidence === | ||
[[File:IQVSMaximumWinterTemp.jpg|thumb|National IQ vs Winter High Temperatures]] | When plotting IQ against winter high temperatures there is a negative correlation value of -.74 demonstrating a correlation exists.<ref name=":0" />[[File:IQVSMaximumWinterTemp.jpg|thumb|National IQ vs Winter High Temperatures]] | ||
=== Criticism === | === Criticism === | ||
There are number of outlier populations that CWT does not directly explain, such as high IQ southeast Asian populations living in warm environments, or the lower average IQs of the indigenous arctic/subarctic | There are number of outlier populations that CWT does not directly explain, such as high IQ southeast Asian populations living in warm environments, or the lower average IQs of the indigenous arctic/subarctic populations.<ref>Lynn, R. (2015) Race Differences in Intelligence: An Evolutionary Analysis, Second Revised Edition. <nowiki>https://www.intelligence-humaine.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Race-Differences-in-Intelligence-second-edition-2015-1.pdf</nowiki></ref> The former may be explained by recent migrations from cold to warmer populations. However, the lower IQs of the arctic populations is more difficult to explain by temperature alone as winters in the arctic are longer and colder than the environments of higher IQ populations. Therefore, winter temperature alone cannot be the sole cause of the increase in intelligence. An alternative explanation for the correlation is the temperature range of an area<ref name=":0" />, where the larger differences would select for humans that can plan and adjust for strategies for surviving the extremes of winter and summer. | ||
=== References === | === References === | ||
Revision as of 02:26, 19 December 2023
The Cold Winters Theory (CWT) posits that average IQs vary geographically due to the difficulty of surviving harsh colder climates selecting for higher IQ. The hypothesis may explain how racial IQ differences could emerge and remain stable.
Origins
In the 1990s, Richard Lynn and J. Philippe Rushton published hypotheses regarding the evolutionary origin of human intelligence in cold environments.[1]
Evidence
When plotting IQ against winter high temperatures there is a negative correlation value of -.74 demonstrating a correlation exists.[1]
Criticism
There are number of outlier populations that CWT does not directly explain, such as high IQ southeast Asian populations living in warm environments, or the lower average IQs of the indigenous arctic/subarctic populations.[2] The former may be explained by recent migrations from cold to warmer populations. However, the lower IQs of the arctic populations is more difficult to explain by temperature alone as winters in the arctic are longer and colder than the environments of higher IQ populations. Therefore, winter temperature alone cannot be the sole cause of the increase in intelligence. An alternative explanation for the correlation is the temperature range of an area[1], where the larger differences would select for humans that can plan and adjust for strategies for surviving the extremes of winter and summer.
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Donald I. Templer, John S. Stephens (2014) The relationship between IQ and climatic variables in African and Eurasian countries, Intelligence, Volume 46. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289614000877?via%3Dihub
- ↑ Lynn, R. (2015) Race Differences in Intelligence: An Evolutionary Analysis, Second Revised Edition. https://www.intelligence-humaine.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Race-Differences-in-Intelligence-second-edition-2015-1.pdf